Cancellation League: Day before upfronts

 

via Giphy

FOX is scheduled to present tomorrow afternoon, so I thought for sure we'd have heard from them by now ... The last post will either be on or before Sunday, May 23 or on Sunday, May 30.

As of now (shortly after 3:30 PST Sunday, May 16), we're waiting on decisions about:

NBC: Zoey's Extraordinary Playlist (on three ballots), Good Girls, Debris, Manifest

FOX: 9-1-1, 9-1-1: Lone Star (on two ballots), The Resident

Of note: CBS killed All Rise (+200), officially killed The Unicorn (I already gave the 400 points for that one) and saved both B Positive and United States of Al. As such, there were no "One and Done" points this year.

Please check your scores. I'll be doing a final audit for everyone.

The Eagle Hand Laundry Company (+2,325, kitty points; +200, kitty points on 11/22; +10, 1/3 kitty; +190, 1/10 kitty; +200, 1/17 kitty; +50, 1/30 kitty; +100, 2/14 kitty; +260, 2/28 kitty; +60, 3/14 kitty; +400, 3/28 kitty; +415, 4/4 kitty; +630, 4/11 kitty; +200, 4/18 kitty; +300, 4/25 kitty; +650, Kat kitty; +230, 5/10 kitty; +430, 5/15 kitty)

Big Sky (+30, title change; -10, Canada; +30, score of 58; +200, backlash; -175, full season)

B Positive (+100, supporting actors out; -10, airing in Canada; +30, Metacritic score of 63; -175, full season; +100, COVID; +200, controversy)

The Unicorn (+50, premiere demo; +200, de facto; +25, multi; +400, ended)

Superstore (+100, lead out; +50, demoted; +600, cancelled)

Ellen's Game of Games

To Tell the Truth (-50, good return ratings; +600, de facto; +1,200, dead)

Kat (-10, Canada; +30, title; +30, Metacritic; +100, COVID; +50, ratings; +50, showrunner)

Equalizer (-10, Canada; +20, delayed; +200, COVID; +30, Metacritic; -50, ratings; -500, ren)

Mother (-10, Canada; +30, title; +100, COVID; +50, 41; +50, ratings; +100, ded; +10, burn)

-- 10,515 points

Jay S. (+2,325, kitty points; +200, kitty points on 11/22; +10, 1/3 kitty; +190, 1/10 kitty; +200, 1/17 kitty; +50, 1/30 kitty; +100, 2/14 kitty; +260, 2/28 kitty; +60, 3/14 kitty; +1,250, Mayor bonus; +400, 3/28 kitty; +415, 4/20 kitty; +630, 4/11 kitty; +200, 4/18 kitty; +300, 4/25 kitty; +650, Kat kitty; +230, 5/10 kitty; +430, 5/15 kitty)

Card Sharks (+300, de facto cancel; +600, dead)

For Life (+100, COVID; +200, end)

Big Sky (+30, title change; -10, Canada; +30, score of 58; +200, backlash; -175, full season)

B Positive (+100, supporting actors out; -10, airing in Canada; +30, Metacritic score of 63; -175, full season; +100, COVID; +200, controversy)

The Blacklist (+10, new cast; +50, prem demo; -500, renewed)

Kat (-10, Canada; +30, title; +30, Metacritic; +100, COVID; +50, ratings; +50, showrunner)

Mixed-ish (+50, demoted; +50, demoted; +100, COVID; +200, dead; +10, burnoff)

Zoey's Extraordinary Playlist (+40, new cast; +50, pulled)

Mother (-10, Canada; +30, title; +100, COVID; +50, 41; +50, ratings; +100, ded; +10, burn)

Prodigal Son (+50, ratings; +200, cancelled; +20, burnoffs)

-- 10,330 points

muggle (+2,325, kitty points; +200, kitty points on 11/22; +10, 1/3 kitty; +190, 1/10 kitty; +200, 1/17 kitty; +50, 1/30 kitty; +100, 2/14 kitty; +260, 2/28 kitty; +60, 3/14 kitty; +400, 3/28 kitty; +415, 4/4 kitty; +630, 4/11 kitty; +200, 4/18 kitty; +300, 4/25 kitty; +650, Kat kitty; +230, 5/10 kitty; +430, 5/15 kitty)

Mom (+100, lead out; +50, prem demo; +100, COVID; +800, cancelled)

Superstore (+100, lead out; +50, demoted; +600, cancelled)

All Rise (+400, controversy; +30, new cast; +200, dead)

Big Sky (+30, title change; -10, Canada; +30, score of 58; +200, backlash; -175, full season)

B Positive (+100, supporting actors out; -10, airing in Canada; +30, Metacritic score of 63;-175, full season; +100, COVID; +200, controversy)

Mother (-10, Canada; +30, title; +100, COVID; +50, 41; +50, ratings; +100, ded; +10, burn)

Kat (-10, Canada; +30, title; +30, Metacritic; +100, COVID; +50, ratings; +50, showrunner)

Mr. Mayor (+200, COVID; +50, ratings; +30, score; +20, no Canada; -500, renewed)

Mixed-ish (+50, demoted; +50, demoted; +100, COVID; +200, dead, +10, burnoff)

Equalizer (-10, Canada; +20, delayed; +200, COVID; +30, Metacritic; -50, ratings; -500, ren)

-- 9,880 points

Havalina (+2,325, kitty points; +200, kitty points on 11/22; +10, 1/3 kitty; +190, 1/10 kitty; +200, 1/17 kitty; +50, 1/30 kitty; +100, 2/14 kitty; +260, 2/28 kitty; +60, 3/14 kitty; +400, 3/28 kitty; +415, 4/4 kitty; +630, 4/11 kitty; +200, 4/18 kitty; +300, 4/25 kitty; +650, Kat kitty; +230, 5/10 kitty; +430, 5/15 kitty)

B Positive (+100, supporting actors out; -10, airing in Canada; +30, Metacritic score of 63; -175, full season; +100, COVID; +200, controversy)

Big Sky (+30, title change; -10, Canada; +30, score of 58; +200, backlash; -175, full season)

For Life (+100, COVID; +200, end)

All Rise (+400, controversy; +30, new cast; +200, dead)

Mom (+100, lead out; +50, prem demo; +100, COVID; +800, cancelled)

Kat (-10, Canada; +30, title; +30, Metacritic; +100, COVID; +50, ratings; +50, showrunner)

Mr. Mayor (+200, COVID; +50, ratings; +30, score; +20, no Canada; -500, renewed)

Mother (-10, Canada; +30, title; +100, COVID; +50, 41; +50, ratings; +100, ded; +10, burn)

The Masked Dancer (-10, airing in Canada; +50, no Metacritic score; +50, ratings)

Mixed-ish (+50, demoted; +50, demoted; +100, COVID; +200, dead; +10, burnoff)

-- 9,820 points

brewfan19_version 2.0 (+2,325, kitty points; +200, kitty points on 11/22; +10, 1/3 kitty; +190, 1/10 kitty; +200, 1/17 kitty; +50, 1/30 kitty; +100, 2/14 kitty; +260, 2/28 kitty; +60, 3/14 kitty; +1,250, Mayor bonus; +400, 3/28 kitty; +415, 4/4 kitty; +630, 4/11 kitty; +200,4/18 kitty; +300, 4/25 kitty; +650, Kat kitty; +230, 5/10 kitty; +430, 5/15 kitty)

NCIS: New Orleans (+10, new cast; +700, cancelled)

Big Sky (+30, title change; -10, Canada; +30, score of 58; +200, backlash; -175, full season)

The Blacklist (+10, new cast; +50, prem demo; -500, renewed)

B Positive (+100, supporting actors out; -10, airing in Canada; +30, Metacritic score of 63; -175, full season; +100, COVID; +200, controversy)

For Life (+100, COVID; +200, end)

Mother (-10, Canada; +30, title; +100, COVID; +50, 41; +50, ratings; +100, ded; +10, burn)

Mr. Mayor (+200, COVID; +50, ratings; +30, score; +20, no Canada; -500, renewed)

9-1-1: Lone Star (+10, new cast; +100, COVID)

Kat (-10, Canada; +30, title; +30, Metacritic; +100, COVID; +50, ratings; +50, showrunner)

Zoey's Extraordinary Playlist (+40, new cast; +50, pulled)

-- 9,470 points

Fancyarcher (+2,325, kitty points; +200, kitty points on 11/22; +10, 1/3 kitty; +190, 1/10 kitty; +200, 1/17 kitty; +50, kitty; +100, 2/14 kitty; +260, 2/28 kitty; +60, 3/14 kitty; +400, 3/28 kitty; +415, 4/4 kitty; +630, 4/11 kitty; +200, 4/18 kitty; +300, 4/25 kitty; +230, 5/10 kitty; +430, 5/15 kitty)

All Rise (+400, controversy; +30, new cast; +200, dead)

American Housewife (+200, controversy; +100, supporting; +500, de facto; +1,000, dead)

B Positive (+100, supporting actors out; -10, airing in Canada; +30, Metacritic score of 63; -175, full season; +100, COVID; +200, controversy)

I Can See Your Voice (-10, airing in Canada; +50, no Metacritic score; -500, renewal)

Superstore (+100, lead out; +50, demoted; +600, cancelled)

Mr. Mayor (+200, COVID; +50, ratings; +30, score; +20, no Canada; -500, renewed)

Kat (-10, Canada; +30, title; +30, Metacritic; +100, COVID; +50, ratings; +50, showrunner)

Prodigal Son (+50, ratings; +200, cancelled; +20, burnoffs)

The Masked Dancer (-10, airing in Canada; +50, no Metacritic score; +50, ratings)

Name That Tune (+20, not airing in Canada; +50, no Metacritic score)

-- 9,455 points

Evil Lincoln (+2,325, kitty points; +200, kitty points on 11/22; +10, 1/3 kitty; +190, 1/10 kitty; +200, 1/17 kitty; +50, 1/30 kitty; +100, 2/14 kitty; +260, 2/28 kitty; +60, 3/14 kitty; +1,250, Mayor bonus; +400, 3/28 kitty; +415, 4/4 kitty; +630, 4/11 kitty; +200, 4/18 kitty; +300, 4/25 kitty; +230, 5/10 kitty; +50, ballot-clearing; +430, 5/15 kitty)

American Housewife (+200, controversy; +100, supporting; +500, de facto; +1,000, dead)

I Can See Your Voice (-10, airing in Canada; +50, no Metacritic score; -500, renewal)

Grey's Anatomy (+20, new cast; +100, COVID; +100, lead out)

Mom (+100, lead out; +50, prem demo; +100, COVID; +800, cancelled)

The Weakest Link (+100, new lead; -10, airing in Canada; -175, full season; -500, renewed)

Mixed-ish (+50, demoted; +50, demoted; +100, COVID; +200, dead; +10, burnoff)

All American (+10, new cast; +100, COVID; -50, ratings; -500, renewal)

Celebrity Wheel of Fortune (+20, not airing in Canada; -50, ratings; +50, no score)

Kat (-10, Canada; +30, title; +30, Metacritic; +100, COVID; +50, ratings; +50, showrunner)

Mr. Mayor (+200, COVID; +50, ratings; +30, score; +20, no Canada; -500, renewed)

-- 9,375 points

Patrick Ausgewahlt (+2,325, kitty points; +200, kitty points on 11/22; +10, 1/3 kitty; +190, 1/10 kitty; +200, 1/17 kitty; +50, 1/30 kitty; +100, 2/14 kitty; +260, 2/28 kitty; +60, 3/14 kitty; +1,250, Mayor bonus; +400, 3/28 kitty; +415, 4/20 kitty; +630, 4/11 kitty; +200, 4/18 kitty; +300, 4/25 kitty; +650, Kat kitty; +230, 5/10 kitty; +430, 5/15 kitty)

The Weakest Link (+100, new lead; -10, airing in Canada; -175, full season; -500, renewed)

The Unicorn (+50, premiere demo; +200, de facto; +25, multi; +400, end)

For Life (+100, COVID; +200, end)

All Rise (+400, controversy; +30, new cast; +200, dead)

The Blacklist (+10, new cast; +50, prem demo; -500, renewed)

Mixed-ish (+50, demoted; +50, demoted; +100, COVID; +200, dead; +10, burnoff)

Kat (-10, Canada; +30, title; +30, Metacritic; +100, COVID; +50, ratings; +50, showrunner)

-- 9,140 points

Franko (+2,325, kitty points; +200, kitty points on 11/22; +10, 1/3 kitty; +190, 1/10 kitty; +200, 1/17 kitty; +50, 1/30 kitty; +100, 2/14 kitty; +260, 2/28 kitty; +60, 3/14 kitty; +400, 3/28 kitty; +415, 4/4 kitty; +630, 4/11 kitty; +200, 4/18 kitty; +300, 4/25 kitty; +650, Kat kitty; +230, 5/10 kitty; +430, 5/15 kitty)

Mom (+100, lead out; +50, prem demo; +100, COVID; +800, cancelled)

B Positive (+100, supporting actors out; -10, airing in Canada; +30, Metacritic score of 63; -175, full season; +100, COVID; +200, controversy)

Big Sky (+30, title change; -10, Canada; +30, score of 58; +200, backlash; -175, full season)

For Life (+100, COVID; +200, end)

Superstore (+100, lead out; +50, demoted; +600, cancelled)

Mother (-10, Canada; +30, title; +100, COVID; +50, 41; +50, ratings; +100, ded; +10, burn)

Mr. Mayor (+200, COVID; +50, ratings; +30, score; +20, no Canada; -500, renewed)

Legacies (+20, new cast; -500, early renewal)

Kat (-10, Canada; +30, title; +30, Metacritic; +100, COVID; +50, ratings; +50, showrunner)

Zoey's Extraordinary Playlist (+40, new cast; +50, pulled)

-- 8,960 points

Lord Dudley (+2,325, kitty points; +200, kitty points on 11/22; +10, 1/3 kitty; +190, 1/10 kitty; +200, 1/17 kitty; +50, 1/30 kitty; +100, 2/14 kitty; +260, 2/28 kitty; +60, 3/14 kitty; +1,250 Mayor bonus; +400, 3/28 kitty; +415, 4/4 kitty; +630, 4/11 kitty; +200, 4/18 kitty; +300, 4/25 kitty; +650, Kat kitty; +230, 5/10 kitty; +430, 5/15 kitty)

Bob Hearts Abishola (+100, COVID; -500, renewed)

American Housewife (+200, controversy; +100, supporting; +500, de facto; +1,000, dead)

Bull (-500, renew)

NCIS: Los Angeles (+10, new cast; -500, renewed)

All Rise (+400, controversy; +30, new cast; +200, dead)

The Masked Dancer (-10, airing in Canada; +50, no Metacritic score; +50, ratings)

Superman & Lois (+20, noCana; +100, COVID; -15, more; -50, reruns; +30, Meta; -500, ren)

9-1-1: Lone Star (+10, new cast; +100, COVID)

Name That Tune (+20, not airing in Canada; +50, no Metacritic score)

Celebrity Wheel of Fortune (+20, not airing in Canada; -50, ratings; +50, no score)

-- 8,815 points

Sillstaw (+2,325, kitty points; +200, kitty points on 11/22; +10, 1/3 kitty; +190, 1/10 kitty; +200, 1/17 kitty; +50, 1/30 kitty; +100, 2/14 kitty; +260, 2/28 kitty; +60, 3/14 kitty; +400, 3/28 kitty; +415, 4/4 kitty; +630, 4/11 kitty; +200, 4/18 kitty; +300, 4/25 kitty; +650, Kat kitty; +230, 5/10 kitty; +430, 5/15 kitty)

Bull (-500, renew)

Big Sky (+30, title; -10, Canada; +30, Metacritic score of 58; +200, backlash; -175, full)

All Rise (+400, controversy; +30, new cast; +200, dead)

Mom (+100, lead out; +50, demoted; +100, COVID; +800, cancelled)

SEAL Team (+20, premiere delayed; +100, shame; +400, cancelled; +20, burnoffs)

Celebrity Wheel of Fortune (+20, not airing in Canada; -50, ratings; +50, no score)

Equalizer (-10, Canada; +20, delayed; +200, COVID; +30, Meta of 54; -50, ratings; -500, ren)

The Masked Dancer (-10, airing in Canada; +50, no Metacritic score; +50, ratings)

Kat (-10, Canada; +30, title; +30, Metacritic; +100, COVID; +50, ratings; +50, showrunner)

Mr. Mayor (+200, COVID; +50, ratings; +30, score; +20, no Canada; -500, renewed)

-- 8,615 points

Amadeus3000 (+2,325, kitty points; +200, kitty points on 11/22; +10, 1/3 kitty; +190, 1/10 kitty; +200, 1/17 kitty; +50, 1/30 kitty; +100, 2/14 kitty; +260, 2/28 kitty; +60, 3/14 kitty; +1,250, Mayor bonus; +400, 3/28 kitty; +415, 4/4 kitty; +630, 4/11 kitty; +200, 4/18 kitty; +300, 4/25 kitty; +650, Kat kitty; +230, 5/10 kitty; +50, ballot-clearing; +430, 5/15 kitty)

Big Sky (+30, title change; -10, Canada; +30, Metacritic; +200, backlash; -175, full season)

The Blacklist (+10, new cast; +50, prem demo; -500, renewed)

Bull (-500, renew)

Card Sharks (+300, de facto; +600, dead)

For Life (+100, COVID; +200, end)

Kat (-10, Canada; +30, title; +30, Metacritic; +100, COVID; +50, ratings; +50, showrunner)

Mother (-10, Canada; +30, title; +100, COVID; +50, 41; +50, ratings; +100, ded; +10, burn)

Clarice (+50, ratings; +30, Metacritic of 55; +100, canceled; +20, burnoffs)

Celebrity Wheel of Fortune (+20, not airing in Canada; -50, ratings; +50, no score)

Legacies (+20, new cast; -500, early renewal)

-- 8,605 points

Cali Wear a Mask (+2,325, kitty points; +200, kitty points on 11/22; +10, 1/3 kitty; +190, 1/10 kitty; +200, 1/17 kitty; +50, 1/30 kitty; +100, 2/14 kitty; +260, 2/28 kitty; +60, 3/14 kitty; +1,250, Mayor bonus; +400, 3/28 kitty; +415, 4/4 kitty; +630, 4/11 kitty; +200, 4/18 kitty; +300, 4/25 kitty; +650, Kat kitty; +230, 5/10 kitty; +430, 5/15 kitty)

B Positive (+100, supporting actors out; -10, airing in Canada; +30, Metacritic score of 63; -175, full season; +100, COVID; +200, controversy)

Bull (-500, renew)

Superstore (+100, lead out; +50, demoted; +600, cancelled)

NCIS: New Orleans (+10, new cast; +700, cancelled)

The Weakest Link (+100, new lead; -10, airing in Canada; -175, full season; -500, renewed)

Mr. Mayor (+200, COVID; +50, ratings; +30, score; +20, no Canada; -500, renewed)

Kat (-10, Canada; +30, title; +30, of 51; +100, COVID; +50, ratings; +50, showrunner)

Legacies (+20, new cast; -500, early renewal)

Mixed-ish (+50, demoted; +50, demoted; +100, COVID; +200, dead; +10, burnoff)

The Masked Dancer (-10, airing in Canada; +50, no Metacritic score; +50, ratings)

-- 8,590 points

Matthew Stechel (+2,325, kitty points; +200, kitty points on 11/22; +10, 1/3 kitty; +190, 1/10 kitty; +200, kitty; +50, 1/30 kitty; +100, 2/14 kitty; +260, 2/28 kitty; +60, 3/14 kitty; +1,250, Mayor bonus; +400, 3/28 kitty; +415, 4/4 kitty; +630, 4/11 kitty; +200, 4/18 kitty; +300, 4/25 kitty; +650, Kat kitty; +230, 5/10 kitty; +430, 5/15 kitty)

B Positive (+100, supporting actors out; -10, airing in Canada; +30, Metacritic score of 63; -175, full season; +100, COVID; +200, controversy)

Big Sky (+30, title; -10, Canada; +30, Metacritic score of 58; +200, backlash; -175, full)

The Goldbergs (+100, COVID)

-- 8,420 points

Whistler (+2,325, kitty points; +200, kitty points on 11/22; +10, 1/3 kitty; +190, 1/10 kitty; +200, 1/17 kitty; +50, 1/30 kitty; +100, 2/14 kitty; +260, 2/28 kitty; +60, 3/14 kitty; +400, 3/28 kitty; +415, 4/4 kitty; +630, 4/11 kitty; +200, 4/18 kitty; +300, 4/25 kitty; +650, Kat kitty; +230, 5/10 kitty; +430, 5/15 kitty)

All Rise (+400, controversy; +30, new cast; +200, dead)

Mom (+100, lead out; +50, prem demo; +100, COVID; +800, cancelled)

Big Sky (+30, title; -10, Canada; +30, Metacritic score of 58; +200, backlash; -175, full)

For Life (+100, COVID; +200, dead)

B Positive (+100, supporting actors out; -10, airing in Canada; +30, Metacritic score of 63; -175, full season; +100, COVID; +200, controversy)

Mother (-10, Canada; +30, title; +100, COVID; +50, 41; +50, ratings; +100, ded; +10, burn)

Kat (-10, Canada; +30, title; +30, Metacritic; +100, COVID; +50, ratings; +50, showrunner)

Mr. Mayor (+200, COVID; +50, ratings; +30, score; +20, no Canada; -500, renewed)

Walker (+20, noCanada; -50, ratings; +30, Metacritic of 51; -175, full season; -500, early ren)

Charmed (+100, COVID; +50, ratings; -500, renewal)

-- 8,245 points

Stegrelo (+2,325, kitty points; +200, kitty points on 11/22; +10, 1/3 kitty; +190, 1/10 kitty; +200, 1/17 kitty; +50, 1/30 kitty; +100, 2/14 kitty; +260, 2/28 kitty; +60, 3/14 kitty; +1,250, Mayor bonus; +400, 3/28 kitty; +415, 4/4 kitty; +630, 4/11 kitty; +200, 4/18 kitty; +300, 4/25 kitty; +650, Kat kitty; +230, 5/10 kitty; +430, 5/15 kitty)

Big Sky (+30, title; -10, Canada; +30, Metacritic score of 58; +200, backlash; -175, full)

Grey's Anatomy (+20, new cast; +100, COVID; +100, lead out)

The Blacklist (+10, new cast; +50, prem demo; -500, renew)

Superstore (+100, lead out; +50, demoted; +600, cancelled)

All Rise (+400, controversy; +30, new cast; +200, dead)

Kat (-10, Canada; +30, title; +30, Meta; +100, COVID; +50, ratings; +50, showrunner)

Superman & Lois (+20, noCan; +100, COVID; -15, more; -50, reruns; +30, Meta; -500, ren)

Mr. Mayor (+200, COVID; +50, ratings; +30, score; +20, no Canada; -500, renewed)

Celebrity Wheel of Fortune (+20, not airing in Canada; -50, ratings; +50, no score)

Walker (+20, not airing in Canada; -50, ratings; +30, Metacritic of 51; -175, full; -500, ren)

-- 8,115 points

rain (+2,325, kitty points; +10, 1/3 kitty; +190, 1/10 kitty; +200, 1/17 kitty; +50, 1/30 kitty; +100, 2/14 kitty; +260, 2/28 kitty; +60, 3/14 kitty; +1,250, Mayor bonus; +400, 3/28 kitty; +415, 4/4 kitty; +630, 4/11 kitty; +200, 4/18 kitty; +300, 4/25 kitty; +650, Kat kitty; +230, 5/10 kitty; +50, ballot-clearing; +430, 5/15 kitty)

Equalizer (-10, Canada; +20, delayed; +200, COVID; +30, Metacritic; -50, rats; -500, ren)

All American (+10, new cast; +100, COVID; -50, ratings; -500, renewal)

The Masked Dancer (-10, airing in Canada; +50, no Metacritic score; +50, ratings)

Mother (-10, Canada; +30, title; +100, COVID; +50, 41; +50, ratings; +100, ded; +10, burn)

Kat (-10, Canada; +30, title; +30, Metacritic; +100, COVID; +50, ratings; +50, showrunner)

-- 7,560 points