What's On Tonight (Wednesday): Second time around

Every Year After

Outwit, outplay! Here's what's on television for tonight, Wednesday, June 10!

Our Top Pick tonight is the premiere of Every Year After (Amazon Prime Video, 3 a.m.). Following The Summer I Turned Pretty, Off Campus, 56 Days, We Were Liars, etc., Prime has carved a niche for itself revolving around young people and soapy romances (and often time jumps) adapted from popular novels. This one kind of reads like a stereotypical Hallmark movie where old flames reconnect and find true love. That is the trajectory, but it expands on the toll returning to a hometown, seeing someone you might not be over, and gives fleshes out the supporting cast. Also, reviews have been quite positive.

Elsewhere, Pearadise gets docuseries treatment, Criminal Record stops the danger, All the Queen's Men still exists, Vox Machina has avoidances, Outlast goes to the jungle, the Brilliant are possessed, and the Bennet Sister has options.

(All times are Eastern. All listings are new unless otherwise stated. For more listings, visit The Futon Critic or Gracenote.)

ON THIS SITE

🍽️ Feed Me (Afternoon): A recipe for discussion and to talk about what you're doing in your kitchen.

💲 Jeopardy! Recap (Afternoon): Jay S.'s daily recap of the day's syndicated Jeopardy! episode, which can be viewed next day on Hulu and Peacock.

EARLY STREAMING & EVENING

All the Queen's Men (Paramount+, 3 a.m.): SEASON PREMIERE. "I See Dead People" and "They Not Like Us"

⭐ Every Year After (Amazon Prime Video, 3 a.m.): SEASON ONE. "Two lifelong friends explore the enduring question - what if your first love was destined to be your soulmate? A sweeping romantic tale about love's timeless possibilities."✔️

Criminal Record (Apple TV, midnight): SEASON FINALE. June and Hegarty must work together to stop the danger already set in motion.

The Legend of Vox Machina (Amazon Prime Video, 3 a.m.): "Doty, take note. We traveled to a place I wanted to avoid. Patch had visions, while I had strong words with my father."

Maximum Pleasure Guaranteed (Apple TV, midnight): Paula's investigation leads her, Rudy and Geri into a standoff. Mallory crosses legal lines in the custody battle.

The Other Bennet Sister (BritBox, 3 a.m.): "In the Lake District, Mary finds herself courted by two suitors."

The Oval (Paramount+, 3 a.m. / BET, 9 p.m.): The U.S. is probably still under attack.

Widow's Bay (Apple TV, midnight): "Please seek shelter should a centuries-old storm rage toward the island and plunge us into darkness. Enjoy a card game."

WHAT ELSE IS ON
💲 America Says (GSN, 6 p.m.)
🎥 The Magic Behind Island Tower at Disney's Polynesian Villas & Bungalows (Disney+, 3 a.m.)
Outlast: The Jungle (Netflix, 3 a.m.): Series premiere

🕗 PRIMETIME 🕙 

Big Girls Wanted: Escaping Pearadise (Investigation Discovery & HBO Max, 8 p.m.): LIMITED DOCUSERIES. "Explores the rise of the Pearadise community and the complex, and at times conflicting, accounts from women connected to it." All episodes air tonight.✔️

Brilliant Minds (NBC, 8 p.m. / Peacock, Thursday): Wolf becomes fascinated with an unusual patient at Hudson Oaks who displays signs of being possessed. It sounds like a wonderful day for an exorcism. Carol and Thorne help newlyweds who are struggling with their sex life. But will they do live demonstrations?

WHAT ELSE IS ON
🏀 2026 NBA Finals (ABC, 8:30 p.m.): Game 4: San Antonio Spurs at New York Knicks
AEW Dynamite (HBO Max & TBS, 8 p.m.)
💲 The Floor (Fox, 8 p.m. / Hulu, Thursday): Season finale
💲 Guy's Grocery Games (Food Network, 9 p.m. / HBO Max, Thursday)
Most Extreme Humans (TLC, 9 p.m. / HBO Max, Thursday): Series premiere
Southern Hospitality (Bravo, 9 p.m. / Peacock, Thursday)
The Valley (Bravo, 8 p.m. / Peacock, Thursday)
WWE Evolve (Tubi, 8 p.m.)

💤😴 LATE NIGHT 😴💤

Adult Swim Smalls (Adult Swims, 1 a.m.): "Fafa tribesmen Gerg and Mani explore Steve's world after following him to the portal."

WHAT ELSE IS ON
Comics Unleashed with Byron Allen (CBS, 11:35 p.m. / Paramount+, Thursday): Alycia Cooper, Dan LaMorte, Daniel Geneen, Dusty Slay
The Daily Show with host Desi Lydic (Comedy Central, 11 p.m. / Paramount+, Thursday): Nina Dobrev
Jimmy Kimmel Live! (ABC, 11:35 p.m. / Hulu, Thursday): Olivia Rodrigo, Zlatan Ibrahimović✔️
Late Night with Seth Meyers (NBC, 12:36 a.m. / Peacock, Thursday): Emily Blunt, Mike Schur, Joe Posnanski
Nightline (ABC, 12:37 a.m. / Hulu, Thursday)
The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon (NBC, 11:34 p.m. / Peacock, Thursday): Hugh Jackman, Niall Horan

Olivia Rodrigo (via Giphy)

—————

Key Sources: The Futon Critic; Gracenote; IMDb; TV Passport
⭐: Top Pick
💲: Game show
📡: Linear broadcast
🎥: Movie
📺: Throwback
✔️: Video/gif/photo included
🏈🏀⚾🥎⚽🏐🎾⛳🏒🏎️🐂: Sports

Happy watching, everyone!