What's On Tonight (Saturday): Days of Hannah's bakes

Hannah Swensen Mysteries

Silly love songs! Here's what's on television for tonight, Saturday, May 16!

Our Top Pick tonight is Hannah Swensen Mysteries (Hallmark Channel, 8 p.m. / Hallmark+, Sunday). A movie series once called Murder, She Baked, tonight's Mystery (Best Served Cold) is the baking detectives 14th outing for Hallmark. Star Alison Sweeney might be more familiar for her Days of Our Lives role or as host of The Biggest Loser.

Elsewhere, Paul McCartney is Live from New York (and maybe Ringo? [*fingers crossed*], Eurovision finds its 2026 song, Kara Swisher Lives on more time, a Duck Dynasty couple gets Lifetime movie treatment, Rooster fights a devil, and Sheryl Lee Ralph picks Two.

(All times are Eastern. All listings are new unless otherwise stated. For more listings, visit The Futon Critic or Gracenote.)

ON THIS SITE

This Weekend in Pop Culture (9:30 p.m.): What pop culture have you consumed lately? This is our weekly thread for you talk about it.

EARLY STREAMING & EVENING

The 500: Immortality at Indy (Fox, 6 p.m.): SPECIAL. A cinematic journey through the IMS Museum that connects the legendary artifacts of the past to the high-stakes ambition of the present. "Immortality! Take it! It's yours!"

Eurovision 2026: Grand Final (Peacock, 3 p.m.): SPECIAL. Live from Vienna! In the early evening hours, the votes will be cast and a winner will be determined.✔️

WHAT ELSE IS ON
⚾ Baseball Night in America (Fox, 7 p.m.): New York Yankees at New York Mets; or San Diego Padres at Seattle Mariners
⚽ NWSL on Ion (Ion, 6:30 & 8:45 p.m.): Chicago Stars at North Carolina Courage / Orlando Pride at Denver Summit FC

Eurovision Grand Finals

🕗 PRIMETIME 🕚

48 Hours (CBS, 10 p.m. / Paramount+, Sunday): SEASON FINALE. "A dangerous secret spans from a deadly Monaco arson to a murder plot in New Mexico."

🎥 Faith & Forgiveness: A Duck Dynasty Love Story (Lifetime, 8 p.m.): "Al and Lisa Robertson's relationship becomes strained under the weight of betrayal and unspoken pain." Pass.

⭐ Hannah Swensen Mysteries (Hallmark Channel, 8 p.m. / Hallmark+, Sunday): When a suspect in a forgery case is murdered and the prosecutor goes missing, Hannah and Chad must uncover how the two cases are connected and solve them in time for the trial.

Kara Swisher Wants to Live Forever (CNN, 9 & 10 p.m.): SEASON FINALE. "Kara investigates humanity's oldest problem, death, by speaking with believers, billionaires, and even an AI version of herself, asking whether immortality is a fantasy and if accepting mortality is the real secret to life." Later, "Kara explores the growing battle between public science and private tech power and what it means for who gets to live longer and healthier."✔️

WHAT ELSE IS ON
🏒 2026 NHL Playoffs (ABC, 8 p.m.): Game 6: Buffalo at Montreal
AEW Collision (HBO Max & TNT, 8 p.m.)
House Hunters (HGTV, 10 p.m.)
🎥 House of Svengoolie (MeTV, 8 p.m.): Rosemary's Baby
📡🎥 Lurker (HBO, 8 p.m. / HBO Max, now)
Primal Combat (National Geographic Wild, 10 p.m.)
🥊 Ronda Rousey vs. Gina Carano (Netflix, 9 p.m.)
Two for One (TCM, 8 p.m.): To Sir, With Love (1967) & A Piece of the Action (1977) with Sheryl Lee Ralph

Kara Swisher Wants to Live Forever

💤😴 LATE NIGHT 😴💤

One Piece (Adult Swim, 2 a.m.): The Straw Hats set out from Zou on their way to win back Sanji and discover one more crew member than they should have. The leading families and leaders of the world make their way to Mariejois for the pivotal world meeting.

Rooster Fighter (Adult Swim, midnight): Keiji and his friends struggle against the powerful Devil, Yuji.

WHAT ELSE IS ON
📡 Blue Lock (Adult Swim, 1 a.m. / CrunchyRoll now)
📡 Dan da Dan (Adult Swim, 12:30 a.m. / CrunchyRoll & Netflix, now)
📡 Tokyo Revengers (Adult Swim, 1:30 a.m. / CrunchyRoll & Hulu, now)
Saturday Night Live (NBC & Peacock, 11:29 p.m.): Will Ferrell, Paul McCartney; season finale

—————

Key Sources: The Futon Critic; Gracenote; IMDb; TV Passport
⭐: Top Pick
💲: Game show
📡: Linear broadcast
🎥: Movie
📺: Throwback
✔️: Video/gif/photo included
🏈🏀⚾⚽🏐🎾🏌️🏒🏎️🐂: Sports

Happy watching, everyone!

Reminder: SNL is tomorrow, therefore the Sunday WOT will be posted a few minutes early!