Cancellation League Update

via Giphy

Welcome to the end of Cancellation League's first quarter! Let's recap the week.

SUNDAY

Bless the Harts, +5, sports

The Rookie, -175, full season order

TUESDAY

Mixed-ish, -175, full season order (kitty points; in the future, I'm going to make sure my ballot includes any leftover show; I hope no one's fun is being too spoiled)

Empire, +5, sports

Emergence, +50, denial of cancellation rumors

WEDNESDAY

The Masked Singer, +5, sports

Almost Family, +5, sports

Stumptown, -125, full season order (-175), but also the hiring of a new showrunner (+50)

THURSDAY

Supernatural, +200, for negative publicity (Jared's arrest)

The Good Place, +200, for belated negative publicity (Danson's arrest)

Let me know if I missed anything.

Jay S. (+30, This Is Us' excessive promotion and new cast; -75, mixed-ish trailer, grade, demo and full season; -185, Batwoman trailer, score, demo and full season; +50, SEAL showrunner; +40, TNF and 9-1-1 promo; +100, S.W.A.T. lead out; +200, W&G feud)
Supernatural (+750, pre-announced cancellation after 13 seasons; +200, negative publicity)
Emergence (-100, successful shopping from NBC to ABC; -10, airing in Canada; +30, trailer; +30, score; +500, de facto; +90, burnoffs; +50, denial)
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit (+50, ratings)
Sunnyside (+20, not airing in Canada; +10, trailer; +50, score; +50, demo; +600, de facto; +50, pulled; -15, additional episode; +80, burnoffs; +50, deny)
Hawaii Five-0 (+50, supporting; +50, ratings)
-- 2,745 points

Havalina (+30, This Is Us' excessive promotion and new cast; -75, mixed-ish trailer, grade, demo and full season; -185, Batwoman trailer, score, demo and full season; +50, SEAL showrunner; +40, TNF and 9-1-1 promo; +100, S.W.A.T. lead out; +200, W&G feud)

Empire (+300, pre-announced cancellation after six seasons; +100, lead out; +200, received negative publicity; +40, new cast; +10, sports)
Stumptown (-10, airing in Canada; +100, lead out; +10, trailer; +20, promo; +30, score; +50, demo; -175, full season; +50, showrunner)

Almost Family (-10, airing in Canada; +60, two title changes; +30, trailer; +50, score; +50, ratings; +10, sports; +600, de facto; +100, burnoffs)

Prodigal Son (-10, airing in Canada; +100, lead out; +10, trailer; +30, score; +20, promo; -175, full season order)

Bluff City Law (+20, excess promotion; +20, trailer; +50, score; +50, demo; +50, DVR; +500, de facto; +60, burnoffs)

-- 2,500 points

Franko (+30, This Is Us' excessive promotion and new cast; -75, mixed-ish trailer, grade, demo and full season; -185, Batwoman trailer, score, demo and full season; +50, SEAL showrunner; +40, TNF and 9-1-1 promo; +100, S.W.A.T. lead out; +200, W&G feud)

The Rookie (+200, negative publicity; +50, supporting player out; +50, ratings; +10, cast; -175, full season)
Evil (-10, airing in Canada; +50, supporting player out; +20, new cast; +50, trailer; +20, score; +50, demo; -500, renew)
Arrow (+400, pre-announced cancellation after eight seasons; +200, four supporting players out; +50, five new cast members; +50, demo)
Almost Family (-10, airing in Canada; +60, two title changes; +30, trailer; +50, score; +50, ratings; +10, sports; +600, de facto; +100, burnoffs)
Perfect Harmony (-10, airing in Canada; +30, trailer; +30, score; +50, demo; +500, de facto; +90, burnoffs)
-- 2,255 points

brewfan19_version2.0 (+30, This Is Us' excessive promotion and new cast; -75, mixed-ish trailer, grade, demo and full season; -185, Batwoman trailer, score, demo and full season; +50, SEAL showrunner; +40, TNF and 9-1-1 promo; +100, S.W.A.T. lead out; +200, W&G feud)
The Blacklist (+50, ratings)
Arrow (+400, pre-announced cancellation after eight seasons; +200, four supporting players out; +50, five new cast members; +50, demo)
Almost Family (-10, airing in Canada; +60, two title changes; +30, trailer; +50, score; +50, ratings; +10, sports; +600, de facto; +100, burnoffs)
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit (+50, ratings)
Bull (+200, received negative publicity; +50, showrunners out; +50, ratings)
-- 2,150 points

RateOfPenetration (+30, This Is Us' excessive promotion and new cast; -75, mixed-ish trailer, grade, demo and full season; -185, Batwoman trailer, score, demo and full season; +50, SEAL showrunner; +40, TNF and 9-1-1 promo; +100, S.W.A.T. lead out; +200, W&G feud)

Bull (+200, received negative publicity; +50, showrunners out; +50, ratings)
The Rookie (+200, negative publicity; +50, supporting player out; +50, ratings; +10, cast; -175, full season)
Madam Secretary (+300, pre-announced cancellation after six seasons; +50, demo)
Fresh Off the Boat (+200, received negative publicity; +50, ratings)
Sunnyside (+20, not airing in Canada; +10, trailer; +50, score; +50, demo; +600, de facto; +50, pulled; -15, additional episode; +80, burnoffs; +50, deny)
-- 2,090 points

Wasteman (+30, This Is Us' excessive promotion and new cast; -75, mixed-ish trailer, grade, demo and full season; -185, Batwoman trailer, score, demo and full season; +50, SEAL showrunner; +40, TNF and 9-1-1 promo; +100, S.W.A.T. lead out; +200, W&G feud)

All Rise (+30, title change; -10, airing in Canada; +20, trailer; +30, score; +50, demo; +20, excessive promos; -175, full season)
Bluff City Law (+20, excess promotion; +20, trailer; +50, score; +50, demo; +50, DVR; +500, de facto; +60, burnoffs)
Emergence (-100, successful shopping from NBC to ABC; -10, airing in Canada; +30, trailer; +30, score; +500, de facto; +90, burnoffs; +50, denial)
Bull (+200, received negative publicity; +50, showrunners out; +50, ratings)
The Blacklist (+50, ratings)
-- 1,805 points

Rocky Jones Space Ranger (+30, This Is Us' excessive promotion and new cast; -75, mixed-ish trailer, grade, demo and full season; -185, Batwoman trailer, score, demo and full season; +50, SEAL showrunner; +40, TNF and 9-1-1 promo; +100, S.W.A.T. lead out; +200, W&G feud)

Almost Family (-10, airing in Canada; +60, two title changes; +30, trailer; +50, score; +50, ratings; +10, sports; +600, de facto; +100, burnoffs)

Bluff City Law (+20, excess promotion; +20, trailer; +50, score; +50, demo; +50, DVR; +500, de facto; +60, burnoffs)

Law & Order: Special Victims Unit (+50, ratings)

Bless the Harts (-10, airing in Canada; +20, trailer; +30, score; +50, ratings; -500, renewal; +5, sports)

Kids Say the Darndest Things (+200, retooled; -10, airing in Canada; +40, trailer; +50, no score)

-- 1,725 points

Sillstaw (+30, This Is Us' excessive promotion and new cast; -75, mixed-ish trailer, grade, demo and full season; -185, Batwoman trailer, score, demo and full season; +50, SEAL showrunner; +40, TNF and 9-1-1 promo; +100, S.W.A.T. lead out; +200, W&G feud)

Prodigal Son (-10, airing in Canada; +100, lead out; +10, trailer; +30, grade; +20, promo; -175, full season order)
All Rise (+30, title change; -10, airing in Canada; +20, trailer; +30, score; +50, demo; +20, excessive promotions; -175, full season)
Emergence (-100, successful shopping from NBC to ABC; -10, airing in Canada; +30, trailer; +30, score; +500, de facto; +90, burnoffs; +50, denial)

Perfect Harmony (-10, airing in Canada; +30, trailer; +30, score; +50, demo; +500, de facto; +90, burnoffs)

Bull (+200, received negative publicity; +50, showrunners out; +50, ratings)

-- 1,680 points

muggle (+30, This Is Us' excessive promotion and new cast; -75, mixed-ish trailer, grade, demo and full season; -185, Batwoman trailer, score, demo and full season; +50, SEAL showrunner; +40, TNF and 9-1-1 promo; +100, S.W.A.T. lead out; +200, W&G feud)

The Rookie (+200, negative publicity; +50, supporting player out; +50, ratings; +10, cast; -175, full season)
Fresh Off the Boat (+200, received negative publicity; +50, ratings)
The Good Place (+200, pre-announced cancellation after four seasons; +50, ratings; +200, negative publicity)
Emergence (-100, successful shopping from NBC to ABC; -10, airing in Canada; +30, trailer; +30, score; +500, de facto; +90, burnoffs; +50, denial)

FBI (+20, new cast)

-- 1,605 points

Stegrelo (+30, This Is Us' excessive promotion and new cast; -75, mixed-ish trailer, grade, demo and full season; -185, Batwoman trailer, score, demo and full season; +50, SEAL showrunner; +40, TNF and 9-1-1 promo; +100, S.W.A.T. lead; +200, W&G feud)

Bull (+200, received negative publicity; +50, showrunners out; +50, ratings)
The Rookie (+200, negative publicity; +50, supporting player out; +50, ratings; +10, cast; -175, full season)
Fresh Off the Boat (+200, received negative publicity; +50, ratings)
Empire (+300, pre-announced cancellation after six seasons; +100, lead out; +200, received negative publicity; +40, new cast; +10, sports)
Stumptown (-10, airing in Canada; +100, lead out; +10, trailer; +20, promo; +30, score; +50, demo; -175, full season; +50, showrunner)
-- 1,570 points

Depressive Pixie Dream Girl (+30, This Is Us' excessive promotion and new cast; -75, mixed-ish trailer, grade, demo and full season; -185, Batwoman trailer, score, demo and full season; +50, SEAL showrunner; +40, TNF and 9-1-1 promo; +100, S.W.A.T. lead out; +200, W&G feud)

The Unicorn (-10, airing in Canada; +40, trailer; +30, score; +50, demo; -175, full season)
Fresh Off the Boat (+200, received negative publicity; +50, ratings)
Kids Say the Darndest Things (+200, retooled; -10, airing in Canada; +40, trailer; +50, no score)
Almost Family (-10, airing in Canada; +60, two title changes; +30, trailer; +50, score; +50, ratings; +10, sports; +600, de facto; +100, burnoffs)
NCIS
-- 1,505 points

chibbs vicious (+30, This Is Us' excessive promotion and new cast; -75, mixed-ish trailer, grade, demo and full season; -185, Batwoman trailer, score, demo and full season; +50, SEAL showrunner; +40, TNF and 9-1-1 promo; +100, S.W.A.T. lead out; +200, W&G feud)

Bluff City Law (+20, excess promotion; +20, trailer; +50, score; +50, demo; +50, DVR; +500, de facto; +60, burnoffs)
Perfect Harmony (-10, airing in Canada; +30, trailer; +30, score; +50, demo; +500, de facto; +90, burnoffs)
Bob Hearts Abishola (-10, airing in Canada; +10, trailer; +10, new cast; +30, score; +50, demo; -175, full season)
The Unicorn (-10, airing in Canada; +40, trailer; +30, score; +50, demo; -175, full season)
Bless This Mess
-- 1,450 points

Fancyarcher (+30, This Is Us' excessive promotion and new cast; -75, mixed-ish trailer, grade, demo and full season; -185, Batwoman trailer, score, demo and full season; +50, SEAL showrunner; +40, TNF and 9-1-1 promo; +100, S.W.A.T. lead out; +200, W&G feud)
Supernatural (+750, pre-announced cancellation after 13 seasons; +200, negative publicity)
Nancy Drew (-10, airing in Canada; +50, supporting player out; +20, trailer; +30, score; -175, full season)
Evil (-10, airing in Canada; +50, supporting player out; +20, new cast; +50, trailer; +20, score; +50, demo; -500, renew)
The Rookie (+200, negative publicity; +50, supporting player out; +50, ratings; +10, cast; -175, full season)
Emergence (-100, successful shopping from NBC to ABC; -10, airing in Canada; +30, trailer; +30, score; +500, de facto; +90, burnoffs; +50, denial)
-- 1,430 points

rain (+30, This Is Us' excessive promotion and new cast; -75, mixed-ish trailer, grade, demo and full season; -185, Batwoman trailer, score, demo and full season; +50, SEAL showrunner; +40, TNF and 9-1-1 promo; +100, S.W.A.T. lead out; +200, W&G feud)

Fresh Off the Boat (+200, received negative publicity; +50, ratings)
Bob Hearts Abishola (-10, airing in Canada; +10, trailer; +10, new cast; +30, score; +50, demo; -175, full season)
The Unicorn (-10, airing in Canada; +40, trailer; +30, score; +50, demo; -175, full season)
Hawaii Five-0 (+50, supporting; +50, ratings)
Emergence (-100, successful shopping from NBC to ABC; -10, airing in Canada; +30, trailer; +30, score; +500, de facto; +90, burnoffs; +50, denial)
-- 950 points

Rami (+30, This Is Us' excessive promotion and new cast; -75, mixed-ish trailer, grade and demo; -185, Batwoman trailer, score, demo and full season; +50, SEAL showrunner; +40, TNF and 9-1-1 promo; +100, S.W.A.T. lead out; +200, W&G feud)

Kids Say the Darndest Things (+200, retooled; -10, airing in Canada; +40, trailer; +50, no score)
Stumptown (-10, airing in Canada; +100, lead out; +10, trailer; +20, promo; +30, score; +50, demo; -175, full season; +50, showrunner)
Bull (+200, received negative publicity; +50, showrunners out; +50, ratings)
The Rookie (+200, negative publicity; +50, supporting player out; +50, ratings; +10, cast; -175, full season)
All Rise (+30, title change; -10, airing in Canada; +20, trailer; +30, score; +50, demo; +20, excessive promos; -175, full season)
-- 915 points

Matthew Stechel (+30, This Is Us' excessive promotion and new cast; -75, mixed-ish trailer, grade, demo and full season; -185, Batwoman trailer, score, demo and full season; +50, SEAL showrunner; +40, TNF and 9-1-1 promo; +100, S.W.A.T. lead out; +200, W&G feud)

Bob Hearts Abishola (-10, airing in Canada; +10, trailer; +10, new cast; +30, score; +50, demo; -175, full season)
Carol's Second Act (-10, airing in Canada; +30, trailer; +30, score; -175, full season)
Perfect Harmony (-10, airing in Canada; +30, trailer; +30, score; +50, demo; +500, de facto; +90, burnoffs)
Bless This Mess
Fresh Off the Boat (+200, received negative publicity; +50, ratings)
-- 890 points

The Eagle Hand Laundry Company (+30, This Is Us's excessive promotion and new cast; -75, mixed-ish trailer, grade, demo and full season; -185, Batwoman trailer, score, demo and full season; +50, SEAL showrunner; +40, TNF and 9-1-1 promo; +100, S.W.A.T. lead out; +200, W&G feud)

Carol's Second Act (-10, airing in Canada; +30, trailer; +30, score; -175, full season)

Nancy Drew (-10, airing in Canada; +50, supporting player out; +20, trailer; +30, score; -175, full season)

All Rise (+30, title change; -10, airing in Canada; +20, trailer; +30, score; +50, demo; +20, excessive promos; -175, full season)

Almost Family (-10, airing in Canada; +60, two title changes; +30, trailer; +50, score; +50, ratings; +10, sports; +600, de facto; +100, burnoffs)

Single Parents (+50, ratings)

-- 855 points

Testicles of Doom 2099 (+30, This Is Us' excessive promotion and new cast; -75, mixed-ish trailer, grade, demo and full season; -185, Batwoman trailer, score, demo and full season; +50, SEAL showrunner; +40, TNF and 9-1-1 promo; +100, S.W.A.T. lead out; +200, W&G feud)

Bless the Harts (-10, airing in Canada; +20, trailer; +30, score; +50, ratings; -500, renewal; +5, sports)
Fresh Off the Boat (+200, received negative publicity; +50, ratings)
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit (+50, ratings)
Sunnyside (+20, not airing in Canada; +10, trailer; +50, score; +50, demo; +600, de facto; +50, pulled; -15, additional episode; +80, burnoffs; +50, deny)
Carol's Second Act (-10, airing in Canada; +30, trailer; +30, score; -175, full season)
-- 825 points

CaliCheeseSucks (+30, This Is Us' excessive promotion and new cast; -75, mixed-ish trailer, grade, demo and full season; -185, Batwoman trailer, score, demo and full season; +50, SEAL showrunner; +40, TNF and 9-1-1 promo; +100, S.W.A.T. lead out; +200, W&G feud)

Stumptown (-10, airing in Canada; +100, lead out; +10, trailer; +20, promo; +30, score; +50, demo; -175, full season; +50, showrunner)

The Unicorn (-10, airing in Canada; +40, trailer; +30, score; +50, demo; -175, full season)

Law & Order: Special Victims Unit (+50, ratings)

Prodigal Son (-10, airing in Canada; +100, lead out; +10, trailer; +30, grade; +20, promo; -175, full season)

Emergence (-100, successful shopping from NBC to ABC; -10, airing in Canada; +30, trailer; +30, score; +500, de facto; +90, burnoffs; +50, denial)

-- 785 points

Amadeus3000 (+30, This Is Us' excessive promotion and new cast; -75, mixed-ish trailer, grade, demo and full season; -185, Batwoman trailer, score, demo and full season; +50, SEAL showrunner; +40, TNF and 9-1-1 promo; +100, S.W.A.T. lead out; +200, W&G feud)

Kids Say the Darndest Things (+200, retooled; -10, airing in Canada; +40, trailer; +50, no score)

Hawaii Five-0 (+50, supporting; +50, ratings)

Law & Order: Special Victims Unit (+50, ratings)

Bless the Harts (-10, airing in Canada; +20, trailer; +30, score; +50, ratings; -500, renewal; +5, sports)

Modern Family (+550, pre-announced cancellation after 11 seasons)

-- 735 points

helent (+30, This Is Us' excessive promotion and new cast; -75, mixed-ish trailer, grade, demo and full season; -185, Batwoman trailer, score, demo and full season; +50, SEAL showrunner; +40, TNF and 9-1-1 promo; +100, S.W.A.T. lead out; +200, W&G feud)

How to Get Away with Murder (+300, pre-announced cancellation after six seasons; +50, ratings)

The Rookie (+200, negative publicity; +50, supporting player out; +50, ratings; +10, cast; -175, full season)
New Amsterdam
The Blacklist (+50, ratings)

The Masked Singer (+20, excessive promo; +10, sports)

-- 725 points

candyoh (+30, This Is Us' excessive promotion and new cast; -75, mixed-ish trailer, grade, demo and full season; -185, Batwoman trailer, score, demo and full season; +50, SEAL showrunner; +40, TNF and 9-1-1 promo; +100, S.W.A.T. lead out; +200, W&G feud)

All Rise (+30, title change; -10, airing in Canada; +20, trailer; +30, score; +50, demo; +20, excessive promos; -175, full season)
Bless This Mess
Carol's Second Act (-10, airing in Canada; +30, trailer; +30, score; -175, full season)
Perfect Harmony (-10, airing in Canada; +30, trailer; +30, score; +50, demo; +500, de facto; +90, burnoffs)
FBI (+20, new cast)
-- 710 points

Evil Lincoln (+30, This Is Us' excessive promotion and new cast; -75, mixed-ish trailer, grade, demo and full season; -185, Batwoman trailer, score, demo and full season; +50, SEAL showrunner; +40, TNF and 9-1-1 promo; +100, S.W.A.T. lead out; +200, W&G feud)

The Rookie (+200, negative publicity; +50, supporting player out; +50, ratings; +10, cast; -175, full season)
All American (-50, demo; -15, additional episodes)
Bless the Harts (-10, airing in Canada; +20, trailer; +30, score; +50, ratings; -500, renewal; +5, sports)
Perfect Harmony (-10, airing in Canada; +30, trailer; +30, score; +50, demo; +500, de facto; +90, burnoffs)
The Unicorn (-10, airing in Canada; +40, trailer; +30, score; +50, demo; -175, full season)

-- 450 points

LurkerWithout (+30, This Is Us' excessive promotion and new cast; -75, mixed-ish trailer, grade, demo and full season; -185, Batwoman trailer, score, demo and full season; +50, SEAL showrunner; +40, TNF and 9-1-1 promo; +100, S.W.A.T. lead out; +200, W&G feud)
Modern Family (+550, pre-announced cancellation after 11 seasons)
Bless the Harts (-10, airing in Canada; +20, trailer; +30, score; +50, ratings; -500, renewal; +5, sports)
Evil (-10, airing in Canada; +50, supporting player out; +20, new cast; +50, trailer; +20, score; +50, demo; -500, renew)
All Rise (+30, title change; -10, airing in Canada; +20, trailer; +30, score; +50, demo; +20, excessive promotion; -175, full season)
Fresh Off the Boat (+200, received negative publicity; +50, ratings)
-- 200 points

Whistler (+30, This Is Us' excessive promotion and new cast; -75, mixed-ish trailer, grade, demo and full season; -185, Batwoman trailer, score, demo and full season; +50, SEAL showrunner; +40, TNF and 9-1-1 promo; +100, S.W.A.T. lead out; +200, W&G feud)

Prodigal Son (-10, airing in Canada; +100, lead out; +10, trailer; +30, grade; +20, promo; -175, full season)
Fresh Off the Boat (+200, received negative publicity; +50, ratings)
All American (-50, ratings; -15, additional episodes)
God Friended Me (+10, new cast)
Bless the Harts (-10, airing in Canada; +20, trailer; +30, score; +50, ratings; -500, renewal; +5, sports)
-- -75 points

Patrick Ausgewahlt (+30, This Is Us' excessive promotion and new cast; -75, mixed-ish trailer, grade, demo and full season; -185, Batwoman trailer, score, demo and full season; +50, SEAL showrunner; +40, TNF and 9-1-1 promo; +100, S.W.A.T. lead out; +200, W&G feud)

Carol's Second Act (-10, airing in Canada; +30, trailer; +30, score; -175, full season)
Evil (-10, airing in Canada; +50, supporting player out; +20, new cast; +50, trailer; +20, score; +50, demo; -500, renew)
NCIS: Los Angeles (+50, ratings)
Bless the Harts (-10, airing in Canada; +20, trailer; +30, score; +50, ratings; -500, renewal; +5, sports)

Madam Secretary (+300, pre-announced cancellation after six seasons; +50, demo)

-- -290 points