What's On Tonight (Saturday): College admissions aren't at this Garage Sale

Garage Sale Mysteries

Atta boy, Luther! Here's what's on television for tonight, Saturday, September 19!

Our Top Pick tonight is the return of Garage Sale Mysteries (Hallmark Channel, 8 p.m. / Hallmark+, Sunday). It's been more than 7 years since Lori Laughlin was dropped by Hallmark after the college admissions bribery scandal. Her Garage Sale Mysteries series ceased... until tonight. The mystery drama follows antiquer Jennifer Shannon as she solves murders. In all my years going to garage sales, I've yet to find murder.

Elsewhere, Billy Strings goes to the Limits, many balls are footed, Lifetime deals with an Ocean, Kara Swisher has News, and iHeartRadio is live.

(All times are Eastern. All listings are new unless otherwise stated. For more listings, visit The Futon Critic or Gracenote.)

ON THIS SITE

This Weekend in Pop Culture (9:30 p.m.): What pop culture have you consumed lately? This is our weekly thread for you talk about it.

EARLY STREAMING & EVENING

Cautiva (HBO Max, 3 a.m.): SERIES PREMIERE. "The story follows a young devout woman who enters a cloistered convent, only to face severe abuses that crush her spirit, alongside themes of survival, justice, and dangerous secrets."

WHAT ELSE IS ON
🏈 CFB on Fox (Fox, 7:30 p.m.): Colorado at Northwestern; or Virginia Tech at Maryland
🏈 Notre Dame Football on NBC (NBC, 7:30 p.m.): Michigan at Notre Dame
⚽ NWSL on Ion (Ion, 6:30 & 8:45 p.m.): North Carolina Courage at Gotham FC / Denver Summit FC at Seattle Reign FC
🐂 PBR Bull Riding (The CW, 7:30 p.m.)
🏈 Saturday Night College Football (ABC, 7:30 p.m.): LSU at Ole Miss

🕗 PRIMETIME 🕚

⭐ Garage Sale Mysteries (Hallmark Channel, 8 p.m. / Hallmark+, Sunday): "One of the members of Jennifer Shannon's true-crime book club is murdered during the group's reenactment of the Lizzie Borden case."

🎥 The Ocean Between Them (Lifetime, 8 p.m.): While vacationing in Belize, an unexpected storm leaves young kayaker stranded at sea. As she battles the elements to survive, her mother embarks on a relentless search that tests her resolve.

WHAT ELSE IS ON
AEW Collision (HBO Max & TNT, 8 p.m.)
🏈 College Football on CBS (CBS, 8 p.m.): BYU at Colorado State
📡 Crossroad Springs (Great American Family, 8 p.m. / Great American Pure Flix, now)
🎥 Dinner and a Movie (TBS, 8 p.m.): Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle
Have I Got News for You (CNN, 9 p.m.): Abigail Spanberger, Kara Swisher
House Hunters (HGTV, 10 p.m.)
iHeartRadio Music Festival Livestream, Day 2 (Disney+ & Hulu, 10:30 p.m.): Special
🏈 PAC-12 College Football Series (The CW, 7 p.m.): James Madison at San Diego State
🎥 Svengoolie (MeTV, 8 p.m.): The Ghost and Mr. Chicken

💤😴 LATE NIGHT 😴💤

One Piece (Adult Swim, 1:35 a.m.): Nami, Chopper, and Carrot encounter some weird and dangerous creatures in the Seducing Woods. Sanji is reunited with Yonji at his family's castle.

WHAT ELSE IS ON
Austin City Limits (PBS, 11 p.m.): Billy Strings

—————

Key Sources: The Futon Critic; Gracenote; IMDb; TV Passport
⭐: Top Pick
💲: Game show
📡: Linear broadcast
🎥: Movie
📺: Throwback
✔️: Video/gif/photo included
🏈🏀⚾🥎⚽🏐🎾⛳🏒🏎️🐂: Sports

Happy watching, everyone!