What's On Tonight (Sunday): Mystic quest

Mystic

I'm sexy, I'm cute, I'm popular to boot! Here's what's on television for tonight, Sunday, January 19!

Our Top Pick tonight is the season premiere of Mystic (UPtv, 8 p.m.). This New Zealand teen drama import, based on the Pony Club Secrets books (no relation to Chappell), begins its 3rd and final season. The series follows a group of horse-loving teens and their efforts to save their peninsula from industrial development. There's also some supernatural element. Tina Belcher would watch this.

Elsewhere, Melissa Roxburgh is Hunting, secrets always Call the Heart, the Witches make a stop, Heroes find emptiness, a Killer calls Lifetime, and CBS goes Square.

(All times are Eastern. All listings are new unless otherwise stated. For more listings, visit The Futon Critic or Zap2it.)

ON THE SITE

Cancellation League (10 a.m.): Walt Disney's Wonderful World of Points. Point Knows Best. I've Got a Point. The Many Points of Dobie Gillis. Have Points – Will Travel.

EARLY STREAMING & EVENING

The Hunting Party (NBC, 7 p.m. / Peacock, Monday): SERIES PREMIERE. "Follows a small team of investigators (including Melissa Roxburgh, Patrick Sabongui) who are assembled to track down and capture the most dangerous killers ever seen, all of whom have just escaped from a top-secret prison that's not supposed to exist." First up is Richard Harris... who, um, has been dead more than 20 years.✔️

Malory Towers (BYUtv, 7 & 7:30 p.m.): Gwen is directing the school play and considers giving Jo a bigger role to take advantage of her father's donations. Felicity juggles rehearsing the play and helping Darrell rehabilitate her ankle. Susan and Ruth help Mr. Murray with his excavation.

Mayfair Witches (AMC+, 3 a.m. & AMC, 9 p.m.): Rowan desperately partners with Cortland to try to stop Lasher. Meanwhile, Moira assists Sip in capturing him.

WHAT ELSE IS ON

🏈 2024 NFL AFC Divisional Playoff (CBS, 6:30 p.m.): 🐦‍⬛  at Bills

🎥 Bring It On (The CW, 7 p.m.)

🇰🇷 When the Stars Gossip (Netflix, 3 a.m.)

🕗 8 P.M. EASTERN / 🕖 7 P.M. CENTRAL

🎥 The Killer Is Calling (Lifetime): "When a mysterious killer targets a remote island town, a veteran 911 operator tries to uncover his motives and save her community, one emergency call at a time." This made me laugh.

⭐ Mystic (UPtv): SEASON PREMIERE. Emotions run high after Issie invites an unwelcome guest to Amanda's birthday party. The KP team have something to celebrate and Issie's confused by her latest visions from Mystic.

WHAT ELSE IS ON

90 Day Fiancé: Before the 90 Days (TLC & Max)

🎥 Beauty and the Beast (The Wonderful World of Disney) (ABC, 8:30 p.m. / Disney+, now): Live action version (yuck!)✔️

Homestead Rescue (Discovery Channel / Max, Monday)

📡 Miss Scarlet (PBS / PBS Passport & PBS Masterpiece, now)

The Real Housewives of Potomac (Bravo / Peacock, Monday)

Worst Cooks in America: Celebs vs. Villains (Food Network / Max, Monday)

Beauty and the Beast (via Giphy)

🕘 9 P.M. EASTERN / 🕗 8 P.M. CENTRAL

Rogue Heroes (MGM+): Paddy leads the SAS (now temporarily named the SRS) into Augusta, but the group is surprised to find the town empty. Making a base in the Chisea Madre Church, the men meet a priest who delivers a proposition - directly from the Sicilian Mafia.

When Calls the Heart (Hallmark Channel / Peacock, Monday): Elizabeth and Nathan uncover Oliver's secret. Rosemary worries Lee has a secret of his own. Allie's interest is piqued when Earl Wyatt returns to town.

WHAT ELSE IS ON

📡 The Agency (Paramount+ with Showtime [linear] / Paramount+ with Showtime [streaming], now)

📡 All Creatures Great and Small (PBS / PBS Passport & PBS Masterpiece, now)

Love Island All-Stars (Peacock)

Married to Medicine (Bravo / Peacock, Monday)

Wipeout (TBS)

🕙 10 P.M. EASTERN / 🕘 9 P.M. CENTRAL

📺 Gilligan's Island (Catchy Comedy, all day): Spend the day with the aftermath of a 3-hour tour gone wrong. Gilligan, the Skipper, the millionaire and his wife, the movie star, even the professor and Mary Ann! "The exiled president of a revolution-torn country visits the island" and appoints the millionaire to the cabinet to begin a plutocracy after winning a tough election. The movie star and the professor tried to warn everyone, but Gilligan is too gullible and the Skipper was too worried about grocery prices.

WHAT ELSE IS ON

💲 Hollywood Squares (CBS / Paramount+, Monday)

📡 Sanctuary: A Witch's Tale (AMC / AMC+, now)

Sister Wives (Max & TLC)

📡 Vienna Blood (PBS / PBS Passport & PBS Masterpiece, now)

Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen (Bravo / Peacock, Monday): Keke Palmer, Wendy Osefo

Rogue Heroes

-----

Key Sources: The Futon Critic; IMDb; TV Passport; Zap2it
⭐: Top Pick
💲: Game show
📡: Linear broadcast

🇰🇷: Korean Drama
🎥: Movie
📺: Throwback

✔️: Video/gif/photo included

🏈🏀⚾⚽🎾🏌️🏒🏎️: Sportsballs

Happy watching, everyone!